Tyler Oaks on the Move: Who’s Intellectual?Tyler on the Move
Volume 7
Issue 16
07/29/2008A few months ago, a friend drove me to a book signing I was doing in her town. After she had fixed her hair in the rearview mirror and applied her lipstick, she pulled glasses out of her purse and put them on. I was surprised.
“I never knew you wore glasses,” I told her.
“I don’t,” she said. “I just want to look smart at the book signing. How do I look? I’m going for that Michelle Pfeiffer with glasses, sexy-smart look.”
I laughed. Then I started thinking about all the bookstores I wished I had worn glasses to over the past several months. Would it have made a difference? Once last fall, I was in a well-loved independent bookstore in the Bay Area. Since it was right before the release of my first novel, I told the owner about my book at the cash register. He looked me over and said I had a lot of nerve to come into his store and talk about my book. He then gestured rather intensely to the book display of a Pulitzer Prize winning author that would be doing a signing the following week. The bookstore owner informed me that I needed to honestly ask myself if I really deserved to be in the same store as people like the other author.
With all obvious respect to Pulitzer Prize winner, what alarmed me more than anything was that the bookstore owner had judged me, my book and my future career without reading one page of my writing. How is that intellectual? Read first, talk later. When we walk into bookstores, how safe are we from intellectual snobbery, or pseudo-intellectual snobbery as I call it? Unfortunately, sometimes not very. Are only books published by Random House even worthy of being opened? If so, then as readers we’ve been reduced to labels instead of design; names instead of substance. Buying a dress for the label instead of the fit is no shallower, image conscious or materialistic than buying books because we are told that those are the good ones.
Northern California is full of bookstores that I love, and I can attest that what finds its way on the shelves isn’t as narrow-minded as the selections as the aforementioned bookstore owner. When I was on my book tour, I did discover places where people were real and wanted to talk about books, letters and ideas. In college towns like Davis or places like the Gaslamp in San Diego, people were more comfortable thinking for themselves, discussing literature in their own terms, sharing ideas that were their own and not necessarily mainstream or, the more serious sin, marketable.
Lately, the irony of superior intellectualism and the glasses-wearing image stuck to it has struck me. Because I was always bookish, a studious girl and woman, I always considered myself to be wearing glasses even though I wasn’t. I forever wished I could play one of those scenes where the quiet woman in the library lets down her hair, takes off her glasses, looks across the table and suddenly is the sexiest thing on the planet. Fun, but honestly, do we really need to wear glasses to be considered smart anymore? Apparently to some people, but I don’t think so. Still, maybe just this fall, I will try those tortoise shell readers I saw at Urban Outfitters.